Legal Status of a Subsidiary

A variant of affiliates is the mutual ownership of two or more companies. Thus, Company X owns fifty percent of Company Y, which owns fifty percent of Company X. (Percentages may vary and more than two companies may be involved.) These are often referred to as sister companies, as opposed to parent companies where one company controls the other over the property. Because subsidiaries must remain independent to some extent, transactions with the parent company may need to be conducted “at arm`s length” and the parent may not have the control it desires. However, the parent company may also be held liable for criminal acts or corporate misdemeanors of the subsidiary. It may have to guarantee the subsidiary`s loans, exposing it to financial losses. “In the legal sense, a subsidiary is a legal person, i.e. it has rights similar to those of a natural person,” explains Marquis. “For example, he has the right to own property, to buy and sell property and to bring legal action against another legal or natural person.” The company that owns the subsidiary may be a holding company, which is a company whose sole purpose is to own one or more companies.

However, the company owning the subsidiary may also be a parent company with its own business activities. In Oceania, accounting standards defined the circumstances in which one entity controlled another. [ref. In doing so, they largely abandoned the concepts of legal control in favour of a definition that provides that “control” is “the ability of one company to dominate, directly or indirectly, decision-making with respect to the financial and operational policies of another company, so that that other company can cooperate with it in furthering the objectives of the controlling company.” This definition was adapted in the Australian Corporations Act 2001: s 50AA. [19] And it can also be a very useful part of the business, allowing any company leader to apply new projects and the latest rules. It is common to set up a subsidiary when a company wishes to carry out a real estate transaction. Let`s take the example of a window and door manufacturer who buys a commercial building for its production. The parent company and the subsidiary do not necessarily have to operate or operate in the same locations. Not only is it possible that they could potentially compete in the market, but such agreements often take place at the end of a hostile takeover or voluntary merger. Since a parent company and a subsidiary are separate entities, it is entirely possible that one of them is involved in lawsuits, bankruptcies, tax offenses, indictments or investigations, while the other is not. Publicly traded companies are required by the SEC to disclose their significant subsidiaries under Section 601 of Regulation S-K. Warren Buffett`s Berkshire Hathaway Inc., for example, has a long and diverse list of subsidiaries, including Dairy Queen, Clayton Homes, Business Wire, GEICO and Helzberg Diamonds.

It is not always possible to separate liability between subsidiaries and parent companies. If any of the parent members are involved in illegal activities or if they do not separate business practices, the parent company may also be held liable. This is called breaking the veil. This is the immersion in the patrimony of the parent in order to obtain compensation in the event of a dispute. A subsidiary is considered wholly owned if another company, the parent company, owns all the common shares. There are no minority shareholders. The subsidiary`s shares are not listed on the stock exchange. But it remains an independent legal entity, a body with its own organized framework and administration. However, day-to-day operations are likely to be fully managed by the parent company. Whether it is to comply with the regulations of a foreign country or to isolate the risks of a real estate investment, various reasons can lead the management of a company to create a subsidiary.

If the subsidiary has valuable proprietary technology, the parent company may attempt to convert the company into a wholly-owned subsidiary in order to have sole control of the subsidiary`s technology. This could give the parent company a competitive advantage over its competitors. A subsidiary is a separate legal entity for tax, regulatory and liability purposes. Parent companies can benefit from owning subsidiaries because they can acquire and control companies that manufacture the components needed to manufacture their products. A subsidiary is simply a company or other limited liability company controlled by another limited liability company and majority-owned by another limited liability company. The company so owned is usually a company, but it may be a limited liability company majority-owned by another company. Most large publicly traded companies have many subsidiaries, often dozens, if not hundreds.

About the Author